What can 3D Bioprinting offer in daily research as a New Approach Methodology (NAMs)? 

Advantages of 3D bioprinting

Benefits of 2D vs 3D cell culture

Till date, cell culture experiments and animal models were successfully used as a research model. The use of primary cells allows the researchers to work with human and patient derived cells while being limited to single layer cultures, co-cultures and two-dimensional models. These setups have been extremely important in the field of immunology, cancer research, toxicology, cell biology studies and many more.

Limitations of 2D culture systems

Even though these 2D in vitro models helped significantly in understanding cellular processes in both fundamental and applied research, these models lack the tissue and organ architecture and complexity. In a natural environment tissues usually do not grow on flat surfaces. Therefore, cell-ECM interactions, cell-cell interactions and other physiological circumstances are missing such as gradients of nutrients, morphogens, oxygen and metabolites.

From spheroids to bioprinted tissues

image oof a 3D bioprinting model
Source CELLINK Bio X6 lab pictures

The development of spheroid technology as well as micro-organoids can be seen as simple 3D cultures. 3D bioprinting brings a technology in the field that allows the bio-fabrication in which cells can grow and interact in a matrix which closely mimics cell behavior and the microenvironment of living tissues. Common 3D models reach from simple spheroids to more complex organoids, and organ-on-a-chip models up to complex tissues.

3D cultures represent physiological structures of tissues and allow more natural cell proliferation and polarization. Simple 3D systems such as self-assembling spheroids were of great importance and used in many research areas but those cannot be controlled in their spatial arrangement of cells.

CELLINK bioprinting technologies help to overcome this issue allowing defined and precise printing of hydrogels or bioinks embedded with cells. A diversity of materials can be used with CELLINK’s 3D bioprinters.

Creating reproducible and scalable 3D bioprinting models

With these open material platforms, you can use multiple materials within one print, such as with the BIO X & Bio X6 extrusion-based printers or the BIONOVA X in-well DLP printer. This helps to create more physiological cell to cell and cell-ECM communication in defined 3D models which leads to a more appropriate study of cell differentiation, migration and signaling. Another big challenge with biological systems is standardization and reproducibility. CELLINK’s technology and its bioprinting software allow a protocol-driven experimental setup that can be reproduced with controlled structures, such as scaffolds, droplets or complex tissues from a petri-dish to multi-well format.

Characteristic2D3D using bioprinting
Support for cells and structure in cell culture– Ustensils (plastic, polycarbonate)
– Flat growing cells
– Homogeneous exposure of all cells to the media
– Extracellular matrix in vitro, naturally growing cells Tissue-like architecture
– Heterogeneous exposure (the upper layer is more exposed than the lower layer)
Physiological relevanceLacks 3D architecture and ECM interactions –Cell junctions Less common, poor cell differentiationReproduced tissue microenvironment, stiffness and signaling, Cell junctions more common (cell-cell communication), better differentiation
Treatment sensitivity,
Drug screening
Cells more sensitive to treatment, poor drug resistance, lacks physiological diffusion barriersCells are less sensitive to treatment (native-like), mimics cell-cell and ECM interactions influencing drug penetration and metabolism
Predictive accuracyLimited to translational relevanceClosely replicates native tissue functions and structure
Scalability and reproducibilityCan be combined with screening and automation platformsRequires specialized bioprinting but high reproducibility

Sources and references

  • Murphy & Atala, August 2014, Nature Biotechnology, 3D bioprinting of tissues and organs, https://doi.org/10.1038/nbt.2958
  • Habanjar et al., November 2021, Int J Mol Sci, 3D Cell Culture Systems: Tumor Application, Advantages, and Disadvantages, DOI: 10.3390/ijms222212200
  • CELLINK, 2D vs 3D Cell Culture Blog, https://www.cellink.com/blog/2d-vs-3d-cell-culture/
  • Edmondson R. et al., May 2014, Assay Drug Dev Technol., Three-Dimensional Cell Culture Systems and Their Applications in Drug Discovery and Cell-Based Biosensors, DOI: 10.1089/adt.2014.573
  • Alemani-Ribes & E. Semino, December 2014, Bioengineering 3D environments for cancer models, DOI: 10.1016/j.addr.2014.06.004  

Related blogs

Biofabrication with living cells
Unlike conventional manufacturing approaches, bioprinting creates living constructs that continue to mature...